Stepsisters Inheritance feud relies upon a 20th Century Law

Stepsisters Inheritance feud relies upon a 20th Century Law

Stepsisters feud hits the headlines as their claim to Inheritance could rely upon a 20th Century Law.

The tragic story of elderly couple John and Ann Scarle who died together

Stepsisters Inheritance feud relies upon a 20th Century Law

Stepsisters Inheritance feud relies upon a 20th Century Law

at their home in Leigh-on-Sea in 2016 continues.

The couple died intestate ( without a Will ) so now, in a bid to secure the family Inheritance,  the step-siblings are at war over which of their parents actually died first.

John and Ann Scarle were found by police after a worried neighbour raised the alert in October 2016. The police ruled out foul play and concluded the couple had died from hyperthermia.

Previous Marriages

As the couple both had children from previous marriages, the inheritance of their estate is not as straight forward as it would be if the siblings were related. If the siblings were the direct offspring of both John and Anne then according to the laws of intestacy the estate would be shared equally between them.

Laws of Intestacy

However, in this instance, the daughters are step sisters so which one inherits depends on which parent died last. For instance, if it was the father who died first then his wife would have inherited the first £250,000 of his estate and all his personal possessions whatever value. ( If there are no children then a husband, wife or civil partner can inherit all the deceased assets up to the value of £450,000 ). If thereafter the wife died then her estate is left to her direct descendants.

In this case, proving which of the couple survived the longest is the goal of both the step-siblings, as one of these two would be set to inherit the couple’s home worth £280,000.

Law of Property Act 1925

Currently, reports are suggesting it is difficult for experts to determine the order of the deaths so, therefore, the court may have to revert to a 20th Century law known as the “Commorientes Rule” meaning simultaneous deaths. Section 184 of the Law of Property Act 1925 states that if two or more family members die and it is not possible to determine who died last then the younger is deemed to have survived the elder.

Both daughters are claiming their parent died last, however in the absence of evidence the daughter of Ann Scarle, Deborah Cutler is relying upon the “legal presumption” that the older of the couple, Mr Scarle, her stepdad died first, so his estate passed to his wife, then when she died the whole estate should pass to her.

This law was introduced during the 2nd world war when a whole family were killed at once during a bombing raid. The House of Lords ruled that in the absence of evidence of who died last then it would be deemed that the youngest would have survived the elder, so the estate would be passed to the youngest and then to their direct decedent’s.

In order for Mr Scarles daughter, Mrs Winter to inherit she would have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Mrs Scarle died first, in order to contest the Law of Property Act.

The case is still to conclude.

Make a Will

This is one of many cases we’ve highlighted where this could have been avoided if only a valid Will was in place. If you would like help writing your Will get in touch today.

For more information get in touch with us at Just Wills and Legal Services on 01342 477102 to book a free consultation.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should not rely on this information to make (or refrain from making) any decisions. Always obtain independent, professional advice for your own particular situation.






Get in touch

Book your free 20 minute consultation with an expert either by video or phone call now

    * Indicates a required field

    Are you contacting us about an existing Will or Product we hold / manage?

    I agree.Sign up for news, advice and guides from Just Wills & Legal Services to help plan your Estate and look after the ones you love. You can opt out at any time and we will never spam you – read our Privacy Policy

    We promise not to share your details with third parties and only contact you with the information you have requested. By submitting this form you agree to receive this information via email. To learn more about our how we deal with your information, take a look at our Privacy Policy